Showing posts with label plot. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plot. Show all posts

Monday, April 30, 2012

[WH] - Why I hate this book.

"'These things happened last winter, sir,' said Mrs. Dean; 'hardly more than a year ago,'" (pg 221).
There are a ton of reasons why I hate this novel, but they all revolve around Wuthering Heights major theme of doubling.
  • The story is frame story in which Lockwood tells the story about how Nelly told him a story in which she took a very minor role.  I think the purpose was to make the events seem more realistic, but frankly, I think it just made the flashbacks more confusing as a time line is almost impossible to form.  The above quote took me forever to figure out the logistics of whether she was talking in the present or the past.
  • I really want to write a story about the protagonist, but unfortunately there appear to be two (if that is even legal).  Cathy drives most of the plot at the Grange, but Heathcliff drives all of the plot at the Heights.
  • Heathcliff obviously seems to be the protagonist, but he is also an antagonist to Cathy at the same time.  At the same time though, it could also be said that Nelly is just as large an antagonist for not letting her love Linton fully.
  • Why would Catherine ever have a baby girl named Cathy?  At least name it Kathy or Quatheryryne or something so I have some way of denoting a difference between the two.  I guess this just shows the similarities between the two halves of the plot.
  • Unless I missed something, Catherine Earnshaw married to become Catherine Linton where as Catherine Linton is engaged to become Catherine Earnshaw.  Did I mention the similarities between Catherine and Catherine?
  • Whose idea was it to name her characters Hindley, Heathcliff and Hareton?  Emily Bronte really seemed to be struggling when she was naming her characters for this book.

[WH] - This book needs an I hate the moors speech...





"Grief, and that together, transformed him into a complete hermit: he threw up his office of magistrate, ceased even to attend church, avoided the village on all occasions, and spent a life of entire seclusion within the limits of his park and grounds; only varied by solitary rambles on the moors, and visits to the grave of his wife, mostly at evening, or early morning before other wanderers were abroad" (pg 158).

Before I get to why I hate the moors, let me first relay to you how much I hate Bronte's syntax throughout her novel.  The syntax was long and complex, probably adding to the confusion she so desired, and succeeded, to create.  Congratulations Bronte, if your goal truly was to confuse your readers to parallel the relationships at Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange, then you have truly outdone yourself this time.  Not only did I become trapped in confusion until the plot finally clicked about 170 pages into the book, but your long and windy sentences that usually contained a plethora of hanging antecedents and dependent clauses usually left me forgetful of where the sentence actually began, which was never where it began.

This, my dear friend, is a moor.  You probably call it a swamp or marsh if you are from the 21st century.
 When I get older, I think that I might move out to somewhere wuthering just off the edge of a beautiful moor.  I mean, look at the view!  You can see for miles.

But seriously, moors are more of a symbol than a setting throughout this novel.  Moors are only home to grass and rarely trees which sort of sums up how Catherine and Heathcliffs initial love was, bland.  Due to the lack of anything stellar on a moor, they are often easy to get lost in (so I hear, I don't believe that I've ever ventured onto a moor before).  This might remind you of Cathy and Linton's love because neither of them really knew where they were going with the love and it became a trap.  Also, moors are pretty infertile.  I don't really know why, but I'm not actually an expert on moors.  I don't know about you, but infertile love sort of draws me to acknowledge Hareton and Cathy's love.  Where did this love even come from?  I feel like they just kind of decided that since they were together so often, they might as well get married.

This book makes me want a pet hamster.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

"How I Met My [second] Husband"

"He always tells the children the story of how I went after him by sitting by the mailbox every day, and naturally I laugh and let him, because I like for people to think what pleases them and makes them happy" (pg 146).

Alright, alright... I have to give Alice Munro mad props for confusing me beyond belief by her witty use of structure. With a title like "How I Met My Husband," I was very confused when I got to the last paragraph and still had no idea how she met her husband.  The order was chronological, but it still managed to throw me for a loop during the entire plot line.  Okay, so I was not so stupid that I actually thought Chris was going to be the husband, but I really started to second guess my pride when it went so long without anything.  The suspense that this prolonged anecdote creates is pure genius!  Not only does Edie introduce a barrage of characters and situations where a new lover really could emerge, but she even went so far as to understate the situations surrounding her real husband.

That sort of plays off of her last statement too.  Edie likes to tell people what they like to hear because she was never really given the confidence that she needed when she was younger.  This really played into the sympathy I gave her just because she did not ever show the pride in herself to assert herself.

The End.

"Interpreter of Maladies"

"It was then that he suggested visiting the hills at Udayagiri and Khandargiri, where a number of monastic dwellings were hewn out of the ground, facing one another across a defile.  It was some miles away, but well worth seeing, Mr. Kapasi told them" (pg 160).

The plot in this structure is very bumpy in terms of suspense and whatnot, but overall seems driven by the internal conflict of Mr. Kapasi.  His lust for Mrs. Das almost got Bobby seriously harmed.

How do you pronounce Das?

Anyways, there were three conflicts in this story.

  1. The most prominent in the story was Mr. Kapasi's struggles against lust and his job.  I looked up what a "malady" was, and it is undesirable disorders.  Now, this could be taken literally since he was a doctor's interpreter, but I will use the next point to further explore the implications of his job.
  2. Mrs. Das's indifference towards everything as a parent easily could have been the most prominent conflict in the story, but it was told too late.  She had the undesirable disorder of indifference and used Mr. Kapasi's interpreter skills as a means to an escape.  Her disclosure in Mr. Kapasi finally led to her to let lose of her fears and help her husband and son.
  3. The final conflict is that of the bloodthirsty monkeys versus the puffed rice and cameras.  Those are symbols of the indifference of the parents by the way.  Not to side track, but I feel like Mr. Das knew about Bobby's father since he was also given a means to provoke the monkey and was actually the one who pushed them over the edge.
P.S.  I miss poetry.